Insurance Assurance

A guide to insuring your heritage home

By Marlene Campbell

 So, your historic building just received heritage designation and you are now one proud homeowner doing your part to preserve Canada’s built heritage. But just a moment, have you thought about what this means for your insurance policy? It does change things, but don’t panic. And don’t try to take back the designation. It’s not that bad. It’s just a matter of doing your homework, getting the facts and putting the proper policy in place. As a heritage building owner, this is something you are probably used to by now.

It is all for your own good because, should the need arise, you want your insurance coverage to do what you assumed it would: protect your investment and restore your building to its former glory.

Determine replacement costs

When insuring a property you need to understand that insurance companies base prices on the replacement cost of a home should it be destroyed or damaged, and the likelihood of that happening. Companies use computer programs to calculate replacement costs based on modern buildings and construction costs across Canada. For example, they’d consider the type of flooring in the house, the siding and the cost of the cupboards.

But that doesn’t work with designated heritage properties, many of which have unique, often elaborate, features that reflect the tastes and skills of their time. There is no computer program that gives the replacement cost of plaster mouldings that require shipping artisans in from different parts of the country — it’s a unique situation.

Before a company will consider insuring a heritage building they require an independent assessment to determine replacement costs. Many homeowners balk at this requirement because they’re required to pick up the cost of a qualified assessor themselves. Insurance companies will not accept a bank assessment done to obtain a mortgage because the bank is interested in market value and the insurance company is interested in replacement value. These are two very different things.

Mary Lambe, office manager of Hickey and Hyndman Insurance in Summerside, Prince Edward Island, points out that a client could pay $100,000 for a building in Summerside that would cost $800,000 to replace after a fire. The assessment, which must be kept current, is an upfront out-of-pocket expense, but the heritage building owner will have the peace of mind of knowing everyone is aware of the replacement costs — no hidden surprises to add to the stress of an unexpected emergency.

To find a qualified assessor check the Canadian Association of Professional Heritage Consultants’ website ( for listings. You can also check your local yellow pages. And talk to other heritage property owners and insurance representatives. Don’t be afraid to ask questions — the answers are free.

Determine the risks

When insurers consider covering buildings they look at the likelihood of a claim. To lower the risk and premium cost they usually like the building to be brought up to code. That includes the heating system, electrical, plumbing, oil tank and roof; older plumbing means a greater chance of water damage, older wiring can lead to fire, and roofs not shingled in the past twenty years may spring leaks.

The Insurance Bureau of Canada’s website ( gives a good outline of what insurance companies are looking for.

To these companies, prevention is the key. It is no surprise then that the number one threat to Canada’s built heritage is neglect of maintenance rather than single catastrophic events so often dramatized by large insurance claims. Some insurance companies specialize in riskier clients, so don’t despair if you can’t do everything immediately.

Be prepared to spend some time shopping around for insurance. After all, this building is likely the biggest investment of your life and you want it properly insured.

Look at local laws

Insurance companies also consider community and provincial legislation around heritage buildings when calculating your premium. For example, when a heritage building is destroyed by fire local laws often require it to be rebuilt on the original site with similar materials. Laws like this could raise claim costs and hence, your premium.

After you’ve insured your home you should keep an eye on any changes the town or province make to heritage legislation and make sure your insurance coverage reflects them. This may cost you money in the short term, but you’ll be glad you did it if you have to make a claim.

Ask lots of questions

It’s great to save money, but when it comes to insuring your designated property, cutting corners may end up costing you more in the long run. Remember that premium cost isn’t the only factor. Make sure to ask about the claims settlement process and the policy’s deductible. Don’t be afraid to shop around and ask lots of questions. Your insurance agent is your partner in preserving Canada’s built heritage. Be prepared to be open and honest with him or her — it will put you in the best position to make an informed decision.

Know where to look

The emphasis, again, is don’t be afraid to ask people in the heritage community questions. Other sources:

  • Check the Insurance Bureau of Canada’s website (
  • Get written material from local insurance companies
  • Ask your municipality for updates on bylaws
  • Check out provincial and municipal heritage protection acts online or by phone
  • Consult the Heritage Canada Foundation (
  • Take a look at the Canada’s Historic Places website (

Like it or not, being proactive is part of owning a heritage building. But the peace of mind is worth the time.

You may also be interested in..

"Close-up view of an intricate antique fireplace in a heritage home, showcasing the detailed stone or wood carvings, with visible testament to unique personal elements and architectural trends of its era."

A Burning Passion: Secrets of antique fireplaces in heritage homes

Stepping into a heritage home, one is often captivated by the majestic presence of antique fireplaces that stand as timeless focal points in the grandeur of the past. These historical treasures not only radiate warmth but also hold within them stories of craftsmanship, materials, and design that whisper secrets of bygone eras. From the rugged elegance of stone-carved masterpieces to the intricate wooden mantels showcasing exquisite artistry, antique fireplaces unveil the geographical and historical contexts of their creation.

Each material used in crafting these fireplaces, whether the enduring strength of limestone or the intricate beauty of carved wood, speaks of resources and skills prevalent in their respective periods. The design of an antique fireplace offers a glimpse into the architectural trends of its time – from the elaborate embellishments of the Victorian era to the classic proportions of the Renaissance period. The awe-inspiring craftsmanship required to shape these masterpieces reflects not only technical expertise but also a deep reverence for the art of creation.

Personalized touches such as family crests, mottoes, or symbolic motifs found in antique fireplaces add a unique layer of history, turning these functional objects into cherished heirlooms. Preserving the legacy of these antique marvels demands a delicate balance of cleaning, repairing, and using historically accurate techniques to safeguard their original allure. Such dedicated efforts ensure that these architectural gems continue to stand the test of time, inviting us to bask in the rich tapestry of craftsmanship that defines our heritage.

Read More »